Q8: November 2019 PLAB 1 Exam Style Question
From 2024 PLAB will be replaced by the UKMLA exam. Check out our services for the appropriate exam.
A 68-year-old woman, who recently moved to the UK from India, presents to her general practitioner's clinic with a six-month history of generalized musculoskeletal pain involving her back, hips, and legs. She also describes progressive difficulty in walking and frequent falls over the last two months. She denies any other associated symptoms like fever, night sweats, or unexplained weight loss. She has no past medical history of note and is not on any medications.
Blood investigations show:
- Serum Calcium: 2.03 mmol/L (Normal 2.2 - 2.6 mmol/L)
- Serum Phosphate: 0.67 mmol/L (Normal 0.8 - 1.5 mmol/L)
- Alkaline Phosphatase (ALP): 270 U/L (Normal 30 - 130 U/L)
Given her symptoms and blood investigations, what is the single most likely diagnosis?
A. Paget's disease of bone
B. Osteomalacia
C. Multiple Myeloma
D. Hypoparathyroidism
E. Skeletal tuberculosis
Answer: B. Osteomalacia
Explanation
Diagnosis:
The most likely diagnosis in this case is osteomalacia, based on the patient's clinical symptoms and biochemical findings. The key findings include low serum calcium and phosphate levels combined with elevated alkaline phosphatase (ALP).
A. Paget's disease of bone:
In Paget's disease, ALP levels are usually markedly elevated, but calcium and phosphate levels tend to be within normal ranges. Moreover, Paget's often presents with localized bone pain rather than generalized musculoskeletal pain.
B. Osteomalacia:
This is the correct answer. The presentation of generalized bone pain, muscle weakness, and abnormal gait, along with low calcium and phosphate levels and a raised ALP, is most suggestive of osteomalacia.
C. Multiple Myeloma:
This is unlikely as there are no B-symptoms like fever, weight loss, or night sweats, and common lab findings like hypercalcemia are not present.
D. Hypoparathyroidism:
While hypoparathyroidism could cause low calcium levels, it would not explain the elevated ALP or the low phosphate levels.
E. Skeletal tuberculosis
Skeletal TB would be accompanied by other systemic symptoms such as fever, weight loss, and night sweats, which are absent in this case.
Clinical Takeaways:
1. Biochemical Markers: Low levels of calcium and phosphate along with elevated ALP are strong indicators of osteomalacia.
2. Investigations: Confirmatory investigations could include a Vitamin D level, parathyroid hormone (PTH) level, and X-rays of the affected bones.
3. Management: Vitamin D supplementation and correction of the underlying cause are the mainstays of treatment.
Summary:
Given the patient's generalized bone pain, muscle weakness, and abnormal biochemical markers, osteomalacia is the single most likely diagnosis. This condition may often be underdiagnosed and requires a high index of suspicion, especially in at-risk populations.
Other answer options are heavily discussed in our platform. Sign up for our PLAB or UKMLA services and get access to all the necessary materials required to pass the exam.
The above question is a high-yield exam PLAB 1 / UKMLA question-style question. At MedRevisions, We provide questions and not only explain the correct answer, we also explain the wrong answer so you will have a comprehensive understanding of the concepts that are commonly tested in the exam. On top of that, we also provide you PLAB 1 / UKMLA exam curated notes at no additional cost.
To discuss to more PLAB or UK-MLA exam questions, Join: PLAB 1 /UKMLA exam study group
At MedRevisions, we strive hard to provide the most up-to-date content available for PLAB Part 1. We constantly add exam-style questions derived from the most recent exam and also update the content to align with the latest NICE/CKS guidelines to ensure doctors pass PLAB Part 1 or UKMLA exam with ease in ONE attempt.
Past PLAB 1 candidates reviews about MedRevisions
How to use MedRevisions effectively for the PLAB 1 exam/ UKMLA exam preparation
Previous PLAB 1 or UKMLA exam guideline update
All MedRevisions recent updates
Check out this Respiratory UKMLA / PLAB 1 exam-style question
What we provide:
✅ 4600+ PLAB / UKMLA exam-style questions
✅ Perfectly tailored PLAB / UKMLA exam style notes
✅ 26 exam PLAB / UKMLA exam mocks
✅ Spaced repetition learning tool